Maruti Swift vs Tata Punch

Maruti Swift vs Tata Punch - Variant and Price

The Swift offers nine variants priced between Rs 7.29 lakhs and Rs 10.56 lakhs, while the Punch has 25 variants ranging from Rs 6.63 lakhs to Rs 11.83 lakhs, all based on Delhi on-road prices.

The base variant of the Swift, the LXi, costs Rs 7.29 lakhs, and the top variant, ZXi Plus AMT, costs Rs 10.56 lakhs. In contrast, the base variant of the Punch, the Pure, costs Rs 6.63 lakhs, and the top-spec Creative Flagship AMT costs Rs 11.83 lakhs.

Comparing the base and top models, the Punch's base variant is a bit more affordable than the Swift, with an almost Rs 66,000 difference between the base models. However, the Punch's top-spec variant's price is higher than the Swift's top-spec model, with an Rs 1.27 lakh difference between the top models. Additionally, the price range within Punch variants is wider than that of the Swift.

The Punch's higher price is due to its advanced features and more variant availability, making it one of the most reasonably priced cars on the market in the compact SUV segment. The Swift also offers low maintenance costs and excellent durability, making both cars budget-friendly options.

Check out:

• Maruti Swift Variants

• Tata Punch Variants

Maruti Swift vs Tata Punch - Exteriors 

With its aggressive lines, elevated posture, and eye-catching LED DRLs, the Tata Punch exudes a tough, SUV-inspired appearance that is both contemporary and durable. In contrast, the Maruti Swift has a clean, sporty design with sharp headlights and a unique grille. 

This table shows how the Punch and Swift differ in their dimensions. 

Maruti Swift

• The new Swift has an assertive and upscale front end thanks to its huge honeycomb-patterned grille and chrome surround. Sleek LED projector headlights with built-in LED daytime running lights (DRLs) flank the grille. 

• The Swift's floating roof design is one of its most unique features. The hatchback looks more dynamic and athletic thanks to the blacked-out pillars and contrasting roof colours that give the impression of a floating roof.

• The Swift has contoured body panels that flow from the front to the back and crisp character lines. Thanks to these creases and shapes, especially around the flanks, the automobile appears more muscular and athletic, giving the overall design depth and energy.

Check out: Maruti Swift Dimensions

Tata Punch

• The tall body, squared-off tyre arches, and high ground clearance of the Tata Punch contribute to its powerful and upright attitude. Despite its small size, the Punch's design gives it a sturdy, SUV-like look. 

• The Punch's twin headlight arrangement is one of its most recognisable external elements. The front fascia has the primary headlights at a higher position, while the bumper houses the secondary lights. This distinctive design feature gives the front end more personality and visual appeal.

• When ordered, the SUV has a two-tone colour scheme, with the contrast roof option for the Tata Punch. The contrasting roof improves the vehicle's overall aesthetic appeal and lends a sporty edge. 

Check out: Tata Punch Dimensions

Maruti Swift vs Tata Punch - Feature & Interiors

Both the models have a well-built interior packed with advanced and functional features to give the car owners more flexibility and comfort.

Maruti Swift

• The dashboard features circular AC vents and dark grey accents, creating a busy look, while black is the predominant colour throughout the cabin. The flat-bottom steering wheel enhances the sporty feel of the interior. However, the analogue instrument cluster with a small digital display in the centre appears outdated.

• Regarding comfort, the seating ergonomics inside the cabin are excellent. The large front seats provide good support and are spacious; top-spec models also include a height adjustment feature for the front seats. The rear bench seats can accommodate three people comfortably and offer ample knee room, though the absence of rear AC vents can reduce comfort on hot days.

• The Swift's features have been updated but are primarily available in the top-spec variants. These variants include amenities such as cruise control, a MID display for the instrument cluster, auto-folding ORVMs, automatic climate control, the SmartPlay touchscreen infotainment system, automatic headlamps, and a 6-speaker audio system. 

Check out: Maruti Swift Interiors

Tata Punch

• The Punch's interior contrasts with its exterior by being simple, minimalistic, and clutter-free, making it easy to look at and live with. The dashboard flows neatly across the cabin, with few physical buttons, especially on the centre console. The chunky steering wheel, contrasting colour treatment on the AC vents, and modern yet simple speedometer console give the cabin a classy look.

• In terms of comfort, the Punch features wide front seats that provide a comfortable driving experience, especially with the high seating position. Rear passengers also enjoy ample headroom, knee room, and foot room, with the rear bench seat offering good comfort.

• Beyond comfort, the Punch's interior provides ample storage space, including a glovebox, door pockets, cup holders, a 360-litre boot, and a cubby hole. The top-spec variant includes features such as a floating 7-inch touchscreen infotainment system, cruise control, projector headlamps, leather-wrapped steering wheel and gear lever, automatic climate control, and automatic headlamps. 

Check out: Tata Punch Interiors

Maruti Swift vs Tata Punch - Engine and Performance

Both models are equipped with top-notch engines that offer reliable performance. The Swift has a petrol engine, while the Punch is powered by both CNG and petrol variants.

Maruti Swift:

• The front-mounted engine has a cylinder displacement capacity of 1197 cc (1.2 litres). This petrol engine features four valves per cylinder and a double overhead camshaft layout, producing a maximum power of 80 bhp and a maximum torque of 111.7 Nm.

• This petrol engine is not equipped with a turbocharger and uses a fuel injection system for fuel delivery. It complies with the latest BS6 emission standards.

• Manual transmission variants are equipped with a 5-speed manual gearbox, while automatic options are available with a 5-speed AMT (Auto Gear Shift) transmission, providing the convenience of clutchless driving.

• The manual transmission petrol variants achieve an ARAI mileage of 23.2 kmpl. The automatic petrol AMT variants offer a slightly improved fuel economy of 23.76 kmpl due to the optimised gear shifts of the auto gear shift transmission.

Tata Punch:

• The Tata Punch is equipped with a 1.2-litre 3-cylinder petrol engine paired with manual and AMT gearboxes. This Revotron engine has a cubic capacity of 1199cc and delivers a peak power of 87.8bhp and a torque of 115Nm.

• For enhanced efficiency, the Punch also offers a factory-fitted CNG option, which provides a maximum power output of 73.5bhp and a torque of 103Nm.

• The standard 5-speed manual gearbox features slick and smooth shifts and light, easy clutch operation. The optional 5-speed AMT automates the clutch operation, adding convenience in stop-go traffic with its creep function for effortless crawling.

• The ARAI-certified mileage for the Punch petrol MT is 20.09 kmpl, and for the AT, it is 18.97 kmpl. The CNG manual variant delivers an impressive mileage of 26.09 km/kg.

Also check:

• Maruti Swift Variants All Specifications

• Tata Punch Variants All Specifications

Safety Features

Maruti Suzuki and Tata have well-equipped the Swift and Punch with essential safety features, ensuring both cars meet important safety standards.

Maruti Swift:

• The Maruti Swift has standard safety features, including twin front airbags, an Electronic Stability Programme with Hill-hold assist, ABS with EBD, and rear parking sensors with a camera. It lacked sophisticated safety measures and solid construction quality. 

• The Swift meets pedestrian safety standards with an energy-absorbing front bumper and a foldable bonnet to reduce impact during a collision. 

Tata Punch:

• Despite being an entry-level SUV in Tata's lineup, the Tata Punch does not compromise on safety. Its robust build quality and comprehensive safety equipment are notable strengths, earning it an impressive 5-star safety rating in the Global NCAP crash tests.

• The Punch is well-equipped with safety features, including dual front airbags, ABS, EBD, ISOFIX child seat mounts, front fog lamps with a cornering function, and a reverse parking camera.

In terms of safety features, the Punch seems to be equipped with more advanced features and airbags. Nonetheless, the Swift remains a popular choice due to its convenient body style and easy-to-drive capability.

Which One Should You Buy?

The Swift and the Punch each offer unique features, aesthetics, and distinctly different powertrains. 

Buy the Maruti Swift if you:

• Are seeking brand value and incredible mileage figures

• Want to experience comfortable driving in the city

• Want reduced maintenance requirements

Buy the Tata Punch if you:

• Want to experience excellent ride quality and handling

• Want a vehicle that provides drivers good confidence with light steering

• Are looking for more variant options and feature-rich interiors

When comparing the Maruti Swift and Tata Punch, each model excels in different areas, catering to varying preferences and requirements of potential buyers. Prospective customers should carefully evaluate their needs and priorities to determine which vehicle better aligns with their expectations and lifestyle demands. While one model may outperform the other in certain aspects, the final decision depends on individual criteria and the importance placed on factors such as design, interior space, performance, and overall value proposition.

Frequently asked questions

Explore more:

• Maruti Swift vs Hyundai Exter

• Tata Tiago vs Tata Nexon

• Hyundai Creta vs Tata Nexon

• Tata Tiago vs Tata Tiago EV