Hatchback vs. Sedan: Which One Should You Buy?

Published on 8 Jun, 2022, 12:40 PM IST
Updated on 20 Sept, 2023, 10:27 AM IST

Team Ackodrive
ReadTimeIcon
5 min read
Interesting Articles
Follow us onfollow-google-news-icon

Share Post

If you are a first-time car buyer or want to buy a car on a budget, you may be more inclined towards a hatchback or a sedan instead of an SUV (Sports Utility Vehicle). If you are confused about making a choice between a hatchback and a sedan, this article is for you. Read on as we provide all the information related to hatchback vs. sedan, and it should give you a clear direction on which one to buy.

Hatchback vs sedan

Hatchback vs. Sedan

The main difference between a hatchback and a sedan is that a hatchback is assembled on a two-box body, whereas a sedan is assembled on a three-box body with a separate boot. A hatchback is ideal for daily commutes, and the sedan is good for highway cruising due to its better stability on the road.

What is a Hatchback?

A hatchback refers to a type of car that is assembled on a two-box body. The engine compartment is the first box, and the passenger compartment is the second box. It comprises 4 doors and a hatch at the rear, opening upwards. The boot of the hatchback is integrated into the passenger compartment and can be accessed from inside the vehicle.

Also, read: Best hatchback cars in India

What is a Sedan?

A sedan refers to a type of car that is assembled on a three-box body. The engine compartment is the first box, the passenger compartment is the second box, and the boot is the third box. Sedans feature a separate boot that is accessible from the tailgate and hence offer more boot space compared to hatchbacks.

Also, read: Best sedan cars in India

Difference Between Hatchback and Sedan

If you look at the parameters like size, comfort, fuel economy, etc., there are subtle differences between a hatchback and a sedan. Here is a table showcasing how different factors vary between the two body types.

Parameters

Hatchback

Sedan

Design type

Two-box design

Three-box design

Size

Smaller than sedans

Larger than hatchbacks

Rear visibility

Higher rear visibility

Lower rear visibility

Cabin space

Lower cabin space

Higher cabin space

Boot space

Generally, a smaller boot space

Generally, a bigger boot space

Wheelbase

Shorter wheelbase

Longer wheelbase

City use

Easier to drive due to compact size

It is more difficult than hatchbacks due to the bigger size

Highway use

Less stable at high speeds

More stable at high speeds

Fuel economy

More fuel-efficient due to lighter weight than sedans.

Lesser fuel-efficient due to heavier weight than hatchbacks.

Price

Less expensive 

More expensive

Resale value

Better resale value

Lower resale value than hatchback cars

Comfort

Less comfortable due to shorter wheelbase

It is more comfortable due to the longer wheelbase

Rear crash safety

Lower

Higher

Pros and Cons of Hatchbacks

Here are the pros and cons of hatchbacks.

Pros of Hatchbacks

Cons of Hatchbacks

Easy to drive in cities

Less stable at high speeds

Higher rear visibility

Lower rear crash safety

Great for fuel-efficiency 

Doesn’t have a strong road presence

Costs less to buy than other body types

The cabin isn’t usually as spacious as other body types

Pros and Cons of Sedans

Here are the pros and cons of sedans.

Pros of Sedans

Cons of Sedans

Easy to drive on highways

Difficult to park due to bigger size

Higher rear crash safety

Lower rear visibility

Powerful engine for a smooth driving experience

Lower fuel efficiency than hatchbacks

A quiet and spacious cabin

More expensive than hatchbacks

Top Hatchbacks and Sedans in India (2023)

Here’s a table with the top hatchbacks available in India as of September 2023.

Model

On-Road Price (Delhi)

Maruti Suzuki Alto K10

Rs. 5.07 lakhs to Rs. 6.38 lakhs

Renault Kwid

Rs. 5.62 lakhs to Rs. 7.10 lakhs

Maruti Suzuki Celerio

Rs. 5.68 lakhs to Rs. 7.81 lakhs

Maruti Suzuki Wagon R

Rs. 5.88 lakhs to Rs. 8.16 lakhs

Tata Tiago

Rs. 5.90 lakhs to Rs. 9.13 lakhs

Hyundai Grand i10 Nios

Rs. 6.11 lakhs to Rs. 9.66 lakhs

Maruti Suzuki Swift

Rs. 6.36 lakhs to Rs. 9.82 lakhs

Tata Altroz

Rs. 7.27 lakhs to Rs. 12.58 lakhs

Maruti Suzuki Baleno

Rs. 7.42 lakhs to Rs. 11.11 lakhs

Hyundai i20

Rs. 8.39 lakhs to Rs. 13.33 lakhs

Here’s a table with the top sedans available in India as of September 2023.

Model

On-Road Price (Delhi)

Tata Tigor

Rs. 6.89 lakhs to Rs. 10.07 lakhs

Hyundai Aura

Rs. 7.14 lakhs to Rs. 10.09 lakhs

Maruti Suzuki Dzire

Rs. 7.35 lakhs to Rs. 10.50 lakhs

Honda Amaze

Rs. 7.95 lakhs to Rs. 10.88 lakhs

Maruti Suzuki Ciaz

Rs. 10.39 lakhs to Rs. 14.`6 lakhs

Hyundai Verna

Rs. 12.73 lakhs to Rs. 20.17 lakhs

Skoda Slavia

Rs. 13.08 lakhs to Rs. 21.73 lakhs

Honda City

Rs. 13.36 lakhs to Rs. 18.46 lakhs

Hatchback vs. Sedan: How to Make Your Decision

While comparing cars, you will find the pros and cons of each model. Ultimately, it comes down to which car serves your needs the best. You should evaluate your options based on power, cabin space, price, driving comfort, etc. It will help you get to a perfect car purchase decision. 

A hatchback would make sense for everyday use when most of your driving is within the city. However, choosing a sedan would be better if you need a car for your family with good legroom and a powerful engine for long journeys.

Frequently asked questions

Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about hatchbacks and sedans.

Icon
Which car is more stable at high speeds, a hatchback or a sedan?

A sedan is usually considered more stable at high speeds than a hatchback due to its larger wheelbase and heavier body.

Why are sedans considered safer than hatchbacks?

Sedans are considered safer than hatchbacks due to the additional metal shield they offer at the rear. The boot area of a sedan can absorb the impact of a crash (from the rear) before it reaches the driver and passengers. However, the safety rating of some hatchbacks may be higher than that of sedans due to other parameters.

Should I purchase a hatchback or sedan with a budget of Rs. 10 lakhs?

You can choose between a top variant of a hatchback or a base variant of a sedan with this budget. The best approach would be to compare both options using the tips given in this article and choose as per your requirements.

Which car is more stable at high speeds, hatchback or sedan?

A sedan is usually considered more stable at high speeds than hatchbacks due to its larger wheelbase design.

Why are sedans considered safer than hatchbacks?

Sedans are considered safer than hatchbacks due to the additional metal shield they offer at the back. The boot area of a sedan can absorb the impact of a crash (from the rear) before it reaches the driver and passengers. However, the safety rating of some hatchbacks may be higher than sedans due to other parameters.

Explore More:

IconTags
car guide article

Recent

Articles

Tata Tiago vs Tata Punch

Team Ackodrive Jun 20, 2024

Hyundai Creta vs Maruti Swift

Team Ackodrive Jun 20, 2024

Tata Tiago vs Tata Altroz

Team Ackodrive Jun 20, 2024

Hyundai Verna vs Tata Tiago EV

Team Ackodrive Jun 20, 2024

Tata Tiago EV vs Tata Altroz

Team Ackodrive Jun 20, 2024

All Articles

icon